top of page
sixmountains.jpg

(Adrienne Richards, 2025 all-candidates meeting)

Election Notebook #12: Organizers of North Cowichan all-candidates meeting, COAP, draw criticism

Adrienne Richards on forest survey: ‘you were allowed to respond as many times as you wanted...trust me I did.’


The sponsors of an all-candidates meeting Sunday at Duncan United Church are proving to be more controversial than the candidates themselves.

Some people have called for a boycott of the meeting.

Some fear an unfair bias.

Others question the group’s beliefs and tactics.

One can expect the questions posed at any all-candidates meeting to be tilted somewhat in favour of the group hosting the event.

And that is certainly no different with Adrienne Richards and Joseph Enslow of Citizens Oversight Accountability Project (COAP).

Six Mountains has seen the list of questions that COAP distributed to North Cowichan candidates in advance of the October 4 meeting starting at 2:30 pm. (The CVRD portion of the event starts at 5 pm.)

The preamble to one question about the Official Community Plan includes: “The North Cowichan OCP was created during the pandemic, when most people were trying to navigate life, save their small businesses, or remain healthy.”

Richards spoke at a public hearing on July 19, 2022, a month before the OCP was approved.

“To summarize the OCP, it reads like a far overreach by local government whose citizens are already regulated and taxed to the hilt and being further restricted in mobility, true sustainability and growth,” she told the public hearing.

Read more on the public hearing: https://www.sixmountains.ca/article/99e97aca-2764-4bbc-a803-8f3885850b1e

(Six Mountains reported at the time that of 128 written submissions received by municipal hall from June 23 to July 14, 2022, 80 percent supported the OCP. Of 43 late submissions, 31 supported the OCP. Further details on submissions at two public hearings: https://pub-northcowichan.escribemeetings.com/filestream.ashx?DocumentId=7203 )

COAP is also asking North Cowichan candidates about climate and transportation plans, spending priorities, growth boundaries, invisible disabilities, street disorder and addictions.

“When the questions are done, for each topic there will be a short yes/no section,” candidates have been told.

It may sound reasonable to give the 14 candidates (among them, conservative candidate Joyce Behnsen, whose list of nominators includes Richards) a chance to fully consider their responses in advance.

On the other hand, that process can punish stronger candidates who’ve done their homework and can think on their feet, allowing weaker candidates time to smooth out their answers with AI — which serves to reduce the value of responses to the electorate.

COAP’s Substack posts come off as polished and somewhat measured, whereas on-line comments can be much different.

Richards recently mocked people who continue to get covid shots or wear masks.

"You are being conditioned — stay home stay safe," she wrote on social media. "Stay in your 15 min cities. You are a human so a parasite on the earth. The government is here for your safety.”

Richards is also a climate skeptic, and has posted: "We are in a cooling period currently."

Also: "We are actually in the end of a mini ice age…." More on the topic: https://science.nasa.gov/earth/climate-change/there-is-no-impending-mini-ice-age/

Richards is the main public face of COAP.

Enslow handles the website, and owns Valley Wise Exteriors.

Both of them, along with Chris Shaw, ran unsuccessfully under the banner of the United Independents in the 2022 election.

sixmountains_edited.jpg

(Chris Shaw, left, and Joseph Enslow stand at 2022 all-candidates meeting. Photo from Nazar Associates Inc. video)


Shaw is seeking election this fall in Cowichan Bay in the Cowichan Valley Regional District. (https://www.sixmountains.ca/article/a1c608c1-5336-4266-b20a-6623aa84997b )

United Independents called for less government in citizens’ lives and asserted that North Cowichan had become a “testing ground for multiple international environmental projects, without public consultation.”

COAP has been the subject of a recent article in The Discourse titled: ‘Behind the backlash to the Cowichan Valley’s comprehensive zoning bylaw. The campaign against Bylaw 4710 was fuelled, in part, by misinformation and an organized group of advocates. What could this mean for the future of local politics?’

https://thediscourse.ca/cowichan-valley/behind-the-backlash-to-the-cowichan-valley-comprehensive-zoning-bylaw

COAP’s response: https://substack.com/home/post/p-212014776

00:00 / 01:04
sixmountains.jpg

​


Richards and Enslow appeared before council as recently as last November to complain about the public consultation into the future of the Municipal Forest Reserve and to encourage continued logging.

The forest reserve is part of the coastal Douglas-fir forest, the most endangered forest type in BC. Find out more: https://www.sixmountains.ca/article/5b6ea833-de31-45f0-9c05-616a3283a050 .

In regards to the on-line forest survey in 2023, Richards has boasted that "you were allowed to respond as many times as you wanted...trust me I did."

Fortunately, there was a process in place to weed out people who voted multiple times.

“Duplicate responses were removed only if there were more than 2 or 3 per IP address, assuming there could be more than one person per household,” Megan Turnock, principal with Lees and Associates, told Six Mountains.

About 100 responses were rejected.

The on-line survey showed 76-per-cent support for two conservation-based management scenarios for the forest reserve. A statistically valid random phone survey of residents showed 67-per-cent support.

sixmountains.jpg

(Results of public consultation on Municipal Forest Reserve)


At the same November meeting at which COAP spoke, council voted unanimously to complete a co-management framework and plan in partnership with Quw’utsun Nation prior to any reconsideration of forest harvesting as a strategic priority.

Halalt Chief James Thomas cautioned council against renewed logging.

Council also received close to 300 emails from the public in response to planned resumption of logging in the forest. About 93 per cent of those emails expressed strong opposition to renewed cutting.

Mayor Rob Douglas has said the results of the consultation should be honoured: https://www.sixmountains.ca/article/0d96a6ff-5053-43fd-a1e3-5a57a10a5b49 .

Read the results of a questionnaire to candidates on the Municipal Forest Reserve published by Where Do We Stand: https://www.wheredowestand.ca/news/candidate-questions-and-responses

Separate questionnaire results from Common Ground Cowichan Alliance: https://commongroundcowichan.org/questionnaire/

Municipal election day is October 17.

Subscribe free to sixmountains.ca to stay up-to-date on election coverage. More than 147,000 unique visitors.

Please consider a donation to in-depth, independent reporting.

— (Larry Pynn received a Canadian Association of Journalists gold award this year for investigative reporting and is currently nominated for his ninth Jack Webster Award.)

— Oct. 3, 2026

sixmountains.jpg

​

​

bottom of page